Proxxon Precision Lathe FD 150/E vs Sherline 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C
Technical comparison · Turning (lathe)
Precision Lathe FD 150/E and 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C are not direct competitors: very different prices (~8.7×). Precision Lathe FD 150/E costs less (~€310) and is the entry-level choice; 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C offers more capability at a higher price (~€2700). Judge them by budget, not head-to-head.
| Parameter |
Precision Lathe FD 150/E
Proxxon
F2 · Intermediate
|
8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C
Sherline
F2 · Intermediate
|
|---|---|---|
| Identity | ||
| Use tier | F2 — Intermediate | F2 — Intermediate |
| Price | ||
| Price (€) | ~280–340 € | ~2600–2800 € |
| Universal specs | ||
| Dimensions (W×D×H) (cm) | 36 × 15 × 15 cm | 28.6 × – × 20.3 cm |
| Weight (kg) | 4.5 kg | 31.4 kg |
| Work area (mm) | 40 × 60 mm | 430 × 110 mm |
| Voltage (V) | 230 V | 240 V |
| Maximum speed | 5000 rpm | 2800 rpm |
| Declared precision | 0.05 mm | 0.0127 mm |
| Category specs | ||
| Swing over bed (mm) | 55 mm | 90 mm |
| Distance between centers (mm) | 150 mm | 430 mm |
| Ecosystem | ||
| Cloud dependency | No | No |
| Software notes | — | The system includes a PC running Ubuntu Linux with LinuxCNC pre-installed, along with a 4-axis driver board built into the computer chassis. A CD with complete instructions and utilities to convert CAD files and TrueType fonts into G-code is included. The operator must supply an external monitor; keyboard and mouse are provided. LinuxCNC is an open-source CNC control package running real-time on the Linux kernel and is compatible with standard G-code formats. |
The differences that matter
- Price: Precision Lathe FD 150/E 310 € vs 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C 2700 € — Precision Lathe FD 150/E wins (+771%)
- Work area: Precision Lathe FD 150/E 40×60 mm vs 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C 430×110 mm — 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C wins (+1871%)
- Distance between centers: Precision Lathe FD 150/E 150 mm vs 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C 430 mm — 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C wins (+187%)
- Swing over bed: Precision Lathe FD 150/E 55 mm vs 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C 90 mm — 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C wins (+64%)
Which one to choose
Choose 8440C 17″ CNC Benchtop Lathe System Package C if…
you value work area, distance between centers and swing over bed.
MakerSpecs is an independent atlas. We don't sell products: this comparison links to both sheets, where you'll find complete data and official links.