Atomstack P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver vs xTool S1 10W Laser Cutter
Technical comparison · Diode laser (405–460 nm)
P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver and S1 10W Laser Cutter are not direct competitors: very different prices (~3.8×). P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver costs less (~€300) and is the entry-level choice; S1 10W Laser Cutter offers more capability at a higher price (~€1150). Judge them by budget, not head-to-head.
| Parameter |
P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver
Atomstack
F1 · Entry
|
S1 10W Laser Cutter
xTool
F2 · Intermediate
|
|---|---|---|
| Identity | ||
| Launch year | 2024 | 2023 |
| Use tier | F1 — Entry | F2 — Intermediate |
| Price | ||
| Price (€) | ~250–350 € | ~1000–1300 € |
| Universal specs | ||
| Dimensions (W×D×H) (cm) | 26.5 × 30.3 × 18.5 cm | 76.5 × 56.1 × 18.3 cm |
| Weight (kg) | 3 kg | 20 kg |
| Work area (mm) | 130 × 130 mm | 498 × 330 mm |
| Z-axis height (mm) | 0 mm | 42 mm |
| Power (W) | 24 W | — |
| Voltage (V) | 24 V | — |
| Maximum speed | 180 mm/s | 600 mm/s |
| Declared precision | 0.01 mm | 0.01 mm |
| Category specs | ||
| Work area (short side) (mm) | 130 mm | 330 mm |
| Rated power (W) | 5 W | 10 W |
| Source technology | Diode | Diode |
| Max travel speed (mm/s) | 180 mm/s | 600 mm/s |
| Max processing speed (mm/s) | 180 mm/s | 600 mm/s |
| Max cut depth per material | Balsa wood up to 3-4mm, acrylic up to 2-3mm in multiple passes | 6 mm basswood |
| Wavelength (nm) | 455 nm | 455 nm |
| Min resolution (µm) | 10 µm | — |
| Autofocus | False | True |
| Rotary included/compatible | False | False |
| Passthrough | False | True |
| Supported software | LightBurn, Other | Proprietary, LightBurn |
| Ecosystem | ||
| Cloud dependency | No | No |
| Software notes | The system offers versatile compatibility and can be controlled either through industry-standard software solutions or via dedicated mobile applications. It fully supports LightBurn for users seeking advanced control over engraving parameters and complex project management, alongside LaserGRBL, an open-source option ideal for Windows environments. Furthermore, the integrated wireless connectivity allows operation through the proprietary smartphone and tablet application, optimizing the workflow for quick engravings directly from graphic files stored on mobile devices without needing a permanent physical computer connection. | The system offers dual software compatibility that expands operational possibilities for both beginners and advanced users. The proprietary application, xTool Creative Space, is available for free across multiple platforms and natively manages the machine's advanced features, such as three-dimensional surface mapping and sensor-based positioning, making the workflow smooth and immediate. For more complex workflows, the machine fully supports LightBurn, the industry standard for laser engraving and cutting. This flexibility allows users to choose between a guided, simplified interface and a professional design environment, although certain manufacturer-specific calibrations may require the proprietary software for optimal configuration. |
The differences that matter
- Price: P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver 300 € vs S1 10W Laser Cutter 1150 € — P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver wins (+283%)
- Work area: P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver 130×130 mm vs S1 10W Laser Cutter 498×330 mm — S1 10W Laser Cutter wins (+872%)
Which one to choose
Choose P1 Ultra Portable Laser Engraver if…
you value price.
MakerSpecs is an independent atlas. We don't sell products: this comparison links to both sheets, where you'll find complete data and official links.